The New York Giants were this close to landing John Harbaugh as their next head coach. Contract talks had progressed. Terms were being discussed. People around the league thought the deal was happening.
And then it all fell apart. Not over money. Not over years. Not over assistant coaching hires.
Over organizational power.
According to The Athletic's reporting, the contract holdup centered on reporting structure. Harbaugh needed it in writing that he would report directly to owner John Mara - not to general manager Joe Schoen.
And when he couldn't get that guarantee, he walked.
Folks, this tells you everything you need to know about what's wrong with the Giants right now. And frankly, everything that's right about John Harbaugh.
Let's start with Harbaugh. This is a coach who's won a Super Bowl with the Baltimore Ravens. He's been to multiple AFC Championship games. He's built a culture of toughness and excellence in Baltimore that's made them perennial contenders.
He knows what a functional organization looks like. He knows what it takes to win. And he knows the difference between a structure that empowers him to succeed and one that sets him up to be a scapegoat when things go wrong.
When Harbaugh asked to report directly to Mara, he wasn't being difficult. He was being smart. He was making sure that if he took this job, he'd have the authority and autonomy to actually build something instead of being undermined by front office dysfunction.
Because here's the thing: in successful NFL organizations, the power structure is clear. Either the general manager has final say and the coach reports to him, or the coach and GM are equals who both report to the owner. What doesn't work is ambiguity. What doesn't work is having a coach report to a GM when the owner is going to overrule the GM anyway.
The Giants have been a mess organizationally for years. They've cycled through coaches. They've made questionable draft picks. They've given massive contracts to the wrong players. They fired a coach who had them in the playoffs just two years ago.
This is not a stable operation. This is not a place where clear lines of authority and responsibility exist.
And Harbaugh saw that. He saw the red flags. He saw the dysfunction. And he said, "If I'm going to fix this, I need to report to the owner. I need to know that I have his backing, not filtered through a general manager who might have his own agenda."
The Giants couldn't - or wouldn't - give him that.
So Harbaugh walked. And you know what? Good for him.
Too many coaches take jobs in dysfunctional organizations because it's their only shot at a head coaching gig. They convince themselves they can overcome the structural problems. They tell themselves it'll be different this time.
And then three years later, they're fired because the dysfunction they inherited became their problem.
Harbaugh doesn't need that. He's already proven himself. He's already won at the highest level. If he's going to leave a successful situation in Baltimore - or wherever his next opportunity comes from - it needs to be for an organization that's willing to structure itself for success.
The Giants aren't willing to do that. Or more accurately, they can't do that because Mara either doesn't trust his own general manager enough to let a coach report to him, or he knows that Schoen isn't the answer long-term and didn't want to put that in writing.
Either way, it's a bad look for the Giants.
And it's a perfect illustration of why some franchises stay stuck in mediocrity while others thrive. The great organizations - the Kansas City Chiefs, the Pittsburgh Steelers, the San Francisco 49ers - they have clear structures, stable leadership, and trust between ownership, management, and coaching.
The struggling franchises? They have power struggles, unclear authority, and coaches who don't know if they're really running the show or just the public face of someone else's decisions.
Harbaugh demanded clarity. The Giants couldn't provide it. The deal died.
Now the Giants are still looking for a coach, still figuring out their organizational structure, still trying to convince someone to take on the challenge of fixing one of the NFL's most iconic but currently dysfunctional franchises.
And Harbaugh? He'll find another opportunity. Maybe he stays in Baltimore. Maybe another team with a clearer structure comes calling. But wherever he ends up, you can bet he'll make sure the organizational chart is crystal clear before he signs anything.
Because that's what championship-level coaches do. They don't just take any job. They take the right job. They demand the structure and support they need to succeed.
The Giants couldn't offer that. So Harbaugh walked away.
Smart move, Coach. The Giants' loss is going to be somebody else's gain.
That's what sports is all about, folks. Power, structure, and knowing your worth. Harbaugh knows his. The Giants are still trying to figure out theirs.
